Russell Wilson or Justin Fields: Who Should Lead the Steelers?
The Pittsburgh Steelers’ quarterback dilemma has been a hot topic this season. Since acquiring both Russell Wilson and Justin Fields, fans and analysts alike have debated who should be the team’s starting quarterback. With a critical game against the New York Jets approaching, Steelers‘ coach Mike Tomlin faces a challenging decision: should the team continue with Fields, who has shown promise in recent games, or give the reins back to Wilson, the more experienced passer?
The Case for Justin Fields
Justin Fields has impressed many with his dual-threat capabilities. In his six starts, Fields has led the Steelers to a 4-2 record and showcased his athleticism by scoring five rushing touchdowns, the highest among quarterbacks this season. His mobility is a significant asset, especially for an offense struggling with injuries along the offensive line. Fields‘ ability to escape pressure and extend plays has been crucial for the Steelers, who are now on their fifth offensive line combination due to injuries.
Fields’ rushing ability has proven invaluable. He has scored touchdowns using both his legs and his arm, providing an offensive spark that the Steelers haven’t seen since Kordell Stewart. Fields’ running game not only leads to points but also reduces pressure on the offensive line, which is grappling with injuries to players like Troy Fautanu and James Daniels. Fields also boasts a solid touchdown-to-interception ratio of five touchdowns to just one interception, ranking the Steelers’ offense fourth in this category.
Though Fields is known more for his running game, he also has potential in the passing game. His completion percentage sits at 66.5%, with a respectable air yards per attempt at 7.3. Fields has also shown accuracy on deep passes, outperforming Wilson last season in passes over 20 air yards by completing 40% compared to Wilson’s 33%. His overall QBR over the past three seasons is 52, notably higher than Wilson‘s 45, showcasing his potential as a balanced threat both on the ground and through the air.
The Case for Russell Wilson
Despite his limited play due to a calf injury, Russell Wilson’s veteran experience and track record make him a strong candidate to lead the Steelers. As a respected captain, he was named the starter heading into the season and has consistently been listed atop the depth chart, even when sidelined. Coach Tomlin has shown loyalty to Wilson, suggesting that he doesn’t believe injuries alone should determine a player’s starting status.
Wilson’s resume is hard to ignore. His experience and deep-ball accuracy could be what the Steelers need to jumpstart their downfield passing game, which ranks 28th in passing yards per game. Wilson’s last season in Denver saw him complete 66.4% of his passes, aligning closely with Fields’ current completion rate. Additionally, Wilson has demonstrated better ball security with only eight interceptions to his 26 touchdowns last year, a substantial improvement from his 16-touchdown, 11-interception season in 2022.
While Fields brings excitement and athleticism, Wilson offers consistency and a strategic mindset. His willingness to target downfield threats could unlock a new level in the Steelers‘ offense, making him a tempting option for Tomlin.
Team Dynamics and Tomlin’s Decision
Tomlin’s decision won’t just affect the quarterback position but will shape the team’s strategy going forward. Fields’ dynamic playstyle has electrified fans and helped the team outscore opponents, with the Steelers averaging 20.7 points per game this season, up from 17.8 last year. However, Fields’ recent games have shown a dip in completion rate, dropping from 69% to 57%, which may hint at some inconsistency. Fields’ off-target throw rate stands at 14%, comparable to Wilson’s accuracy, yet his unique mobility makes him a valuable weapon in an offense constrained by injuries.
On the other hand, Wilson’s presence could bring stability. Known for his ability to read defenses and throw with accuracy, Wilson’s experience might help the Steelers overcome their passing struggles. His steady hand and game management skills could be invaluable in high-stakes situations.
What Lies Ahead for the Steelers?
As Tomlin prepares for the game against the Jets, he faces a choice that goes beyond statistics and game performance. As he recently stated, “Stats are often for losers. It’s comfort food when you’re taking an L.” Tomlin’s primary focus is positioning his team for victory. He could opt to give Wilson the starting role, trusting his veteran experience, or continue with Fields, banking on his momentum and unique playstyle. Alternatively, Tomlin may consider a dual-quarterback system that leverages both players’ strengths.
Fields’ performance has shown he can handle the pressures of the NFL, and his connection with teammates has been evident. However, Wilson’s seasoned approach and leadership offer stability that may be essential for a team looking to make a deep playoff run. Tomlin’s ultimate choice will define the direction of the Steelers’ season and influence the team’s competitive edge.
In the end, it’s a decision that only Tomlin can make, balancing Fields’ electrifying potential with Wilson’s proven expertise. Whether it’s Fields, Wilson, or a combination of both, Tomlin’s call will reflect his commitment to winning and positioning the Steelers as a formidable force in the league.
