Lamar Jackson: The NFL’s Most Overrated Star?
Lamar Jackson, with two MVP titles and a $260 million contract, is often considered one of the NFL’s brightest stars. However, beneath the accolades lies a debate—does Jackson’s performance truly justify the praise? While his athleticism is undeniable, critics question whether he deserves the titles and recognition he’s garnered, especially given his lackluster postseason record and average passing stats.
Lamar Jackson’s MVP Titles: Overhyped or Earned?
At just 27, Jackson has earned two league MVP awards, placing him among legends like Joe Montana. Yet, his passing stats tell a different story. In the 2023 season, Jackson ranked 19th in passing yards per game and 11th in touchdowns, with a modest 3,678 yards and 24 touchdowns. Comparatively, San Francisco 49ers’ Brock Purdy led the NFC with 4,280 yards and 31 touchdowns, and even rookies like C.J. Stroud have surpassed Jackson’s numbers in recent years.
Despite these middling stats, Jackson continues to be celebrated, sparking criticism that his MVP titles reflect media hype rather than true on-field excellence. In an era of offensive dominance, where records are shattered regularly, Jackson’s numbers seem average at best, raising the question: Is he really deserving of two MVP awards?
Postseason Woes: Jackson’s Achilles Heel
Jackson’s postseason performance has only deepened the doubts. His playoff record stands at 2-4, with both wins coming against weaker teams. When facing stronger opposition, Jackson has consistently struggled, especially when his defense allows more than 13 points. His inability to step up in critical moments has cost his team, despite stellar defensive efforts that kept opponents like Patrick Mahomes at bay.
In six postseason games, Jackson has thrown for just six touchdowns and six interceptions, with a passer rating of 79.7—lower than less celebrated players like Vinny Testaverde and Jake Delhomme. Additionally, his playoff completion rate of 57% falls far below expectations, further emphasizing his difficulties under pressure.
Is Lamar Jackson Overrated?
The narrative around Lamar Jackson’s talent is complicated. While his ability to make plays with his legs is exceptional, critics argue he lacks the passing proficiency to be considered among the NFL’s elite quarterbacks. In the playoffs, Jackson has three rushing touchdowns but also two lost fumbles, contributing to an overall mixed postseason performance. Despite his dynamic skill set, his inability to consistently perform as a passer casts a shadow over his career achievements.
With the 2023 season offering a clear path to success—given challenges faced by Kansas City, Buffalo, and Cincinnati—Jackson had a prime opportunity to lead the Ravens to glory. Yet, his inability to seize the moment has led to further scrutiny.
Lamar Jackson’s Legacy
While Lamar Jackson has undoubtedly been one of the most exciting players in the NFL, his accolades, particularly his MVP titles, may be inflated by media narratives. His passing statistics are underwhelming, and his postseason struggles are hard to ignore. Jackson’s future will depend on whether he can overcome these shortcomings and prove that his success isn’t just a product of hype, but of true skill and leadership. Until then, the debate about whether he’s the most overrated player in the NFL continues.
