The CMA Awards’ decision to exclude Beyoncé’s critically acclaimed album Cowboy Carter from this year’s nominations has ignited fiery reactions from fans, artists, and insiders. While the album broke records as the first by a Black woman to top the Top Country Albums chart, its absence from country music’s biggest night raises questions about industry gatekeeping.
Billy Ray Cyrus Speaks Out: “She Doesn’t Need Their Trophy”
Country legend Billy Ray Cyrus voiced his shock over the snub on Instagram, praising Cowboy Carter as a masterpiece. “Her album was brilliant. Her single ruled. She doesn’t need a trophy from the CMA or anyone’s approval,” he wrote, referencing his own experience with Lil Nas X’s Old Town Road, which faced similar skepticism before dominating the charts. Cyrus even quoted Muhammad Ali, adding, “When ya knock ’em out… ya don’t need no judge.”
Divided Reactions: Industry Insiders Weigh In
While Dolly Parton diplomatically attributed the omission to a crowded field of deserving nominees, Kelly Clarkson wasn’t as forgiving. She pointed to her own struggles with country music’s resistance to outsiders, recalling a blunt warning she received to “quit pop music” if she wanted airplay. Meanwhile, host Luke Bryan sparked outrage by suggesting Beyoncé should “be country with us a little bit,” a comment he later claimed was misunderstood.
A Systemic Snub or Just Bad Luck?
The exclusion feels deliberate to many, especially since Beyoncé previously faced backlash after performing at the 2016 CMA Awards with The Chicks. Critics argue her snub reflects the genre’s unwillingness to fully embrace diverse voices, even as Cowboy Carter redefines what country music can be.
As fans prepare for tonight’s CMA Awards, the Beyoncé controversy looms large, leaving the country music establishment with tough questions about inclusivity and evolution. Will the genre learn to embrace change—or risk alienating future trailblazers?
