Justin Fields appears open to the idea of being benched in favor of Russell Wilson, despite the Pittsburgh Steelers holding a 4-2 record and sharing first place with Baltimore in the AFC North. Although Fields has contributed positively while stepping in for Wilson, who’s been recovering from a calf injury, the fourth-year quarterback acknowledges that his performance might not be enough to convince Coach Mike Tomlin to keep him as the starting quarterback when Wilson returns to full health.
“If I’m being real with myself, I don’t think I played good enough,” Fields admitted on Thursday. “If I had played well enough, I don’t think there’d be any ‘who should play, who shouldn’t’ discussion.”
While Tomlin has not officially named a starter for Sunday night’s game against the New York Jets (also 4-2), indications strongly suggest Wilson will debut for Pittsburgh. The 35-year-old, a nine-time Pro Bowler, has taken extended snaps with the first team this week. Further signaling a potential lineup change, Fields addressed the media before Thursday’s practice—a departure from his usual post-practice routine throughout the season.
Tomlin hinted at the possibility of Wilson’s return, noting that while Fields and the Steelers have shown “really good” moments this season, they’re “not to be confused with great.” Fields, meanwhile, has scored 10 touchdowns (five passing, five rushing) while limiting turnovers to three (one interception, two fumbles). Despite these stats, his accuracy has waned in recent weeks, and with a challenging second-half schedule looming after the team’s early November bye, Tomlin seems ready to see what Wilson could offer the team.
Fields has earned praise from both Tomlin and first-year offensive coordinator Arthur Smith for his maturity and selflessness. Tomlin has consistently applauded Fields’ resilience, while Smith has commended the 25-year-old’s attitude, especially his willingness to take accountability for his performance. “That’s why you love working with Justin; it’s genuine,” Smith remarked. “It’s not just a cliche or something somebody told him to say.”
Acquired from Chicago shortly after the Steelers signed Wilson to a one-year deal, Fields downplayed any emotional impact the potential benching might have. “I’m just here to do my job,” he said. “Whether that’s playing, helping out on the sideline, or supporting Russ if he’s out there.” Both quarterbacks seem to have fostered a positive relationship. Wilson was notably animated, cheering as Fields dashed into the end zone during a game against the Raiders, and Fields has consistently shown respect for Wilson’s experience and established standing in the NFL.
The Steelers‘ decision underscores their unique position, as they evaluate both quarterbacks who could become free agents next spring. By giving Wilson a chance to play, Tomlin can assess each player’s long-term potential for the franchise. While Pittsburgh is off to a strong start, Tomlin has reminded his players that “stats are often for losers” and that wins, not individual metrics, ultimately define success.
Reflecting on this team philosophy, offensive coordinator Smith addressed potential concerns about Fields’ confidence if Wilson takes the reins. “He’s 4-2,” Smith said. “He’s been productive.” Yet, it seems Fields’ output hasn’t been quite enough to secure him the starting role—at least for now.
This quarterback situation is markedly different from a year ago when Pittsburgh, with a similar 4-2 record, remained firmly committed to Kenny Pickett as their franchise quarterback. At the time, Pickett’s backups lacked Wilson’s accomplishments, making Pickett the clear starter despite the offense’s struggles. With Wilson now in the mix, the Steelers have more options, and giving the veteran quarterback a chance could prove valuable for both the team’s short-term goals and long-term roster decisions.
As the Steelers prepare for their matchup against the Jets, all eyes will be on Coach Tomlin’s decision, which may have a significant impact on the team’s future quarterback plans. Fields, for his part, appears ready to adapt, showing the humility and resilience that have become defining aspects of his career.
